‘We didn’t live – we starved’: Poverty and ‘foreign markets’ in 19th Century Whitechapel

Screen Shot 2020-02-15 at 11.29.41

In my last post I started walking the streets of East London with Charles Booth’s poverty survey as my guide. Moving on from Gunthorpe and Flower and Dean Walk (which in the 1880s was George Street and Flower and Dean Street respectively) in this post I’ve arrived at Wentworth Street.

In the late nineteenth century Wentworth Street was extremely poor. In Booth’s original map (above) it is a mixture of colours from red to pink to blue but since it abuts George Yard, Thrawl Street and other courts and alleys associated with the ‘Abyss’ we can confidently assume that most people living here were living close or below what Seebohm Rowntree was later to define as the ‘poverty line.

This story, reported in the Manchester press, gives us some idea of exactly what conditions were like in and around Wentworth Street in the last decade of the 1800s.

In early November 1893 Mr Wynne Baxter, the local coroner (and the man that had presided over the inquests into most of the Whitechapel murder victims in 1888), convened an inquest on the death of Elizabeth Newton.

Elizabeth was only four months old; she was the illegitimate daughter of Martha Newton who lived at 75 Wentworth Street. The paper described Martha as a ‘poor, miserable-looking girl’ who lived with her mother.

At the time little Elizabeth had been born Martha was living in a local lodging house, and went to the infirmary to give birth. Once the child and mother left hospital they went to live with Martha’s mother Margaret but the conditions were awful.

‘Her mother only occupied one room’, the inquest was told. So Martha and her baby joined her ‘sister, aged eight years […] and her other illegitimate child, aged two’, in the room.

Margaret Newton was desperately poor and the augmented family struggled to feed itself. Margaret told Mr Baxter that Marth fed her newborn on ‘cornflour, arrowroot, or anything the mother could get for it’. She herself only earned 1s3d to 1s 6da day.

How much was the rent, the coroner asked her. ‘Five shillings’, was the reply.

‘How do you live’?

‘We didn’t live – we starved’, Margaret Newton told him.

The final witness was the doctor who declared Elizabeth dead. She weighed only 3lb 12oz when he examined her. He told a stunned court that she should have weighed at least 11b by then. The coroners’ jury delivered a verdict of ‘death by malnutrition’.

Sadly Elizabeth’s death was not uncommon in late nineteenth-century London. Without an effective system of state benefits or health service that was free at the point of need, many children succumbed to poverty and lack of nutrition in Victoria’s Britain.

In the 1880s and 1890s Wentworth Street was busy during the day and early evening. As Charles Booth observed it was:

 ‘thronged every day by stalls, both buyers and sellers nearly all but not altogether Jews, women bareheaded, bewigged, coarse woolen shawls over shoulders, more like a foreign market scene than anything English’.

The red on the map probably refereed to ‘the small shops and houses on the North side’, the poor were absent except in the nearby courts.

Today, as I found out on my walk, there is very little remaining of nineteenth-century Wentworth Street. This is hardly surprising when you consider that this area was very heavily bombed during the Second World War (see map from www.bombsight.org) and post war council rebuilding and slum clearance.

Screen Shot 2020-02-15 at 11.56.50

There was still a strong Jewish community in and around Wentworth Street during and after WW2. Helen Shaw (Schevitch) remembered life back then:

We had one kitchen at the back of our house, which was like a scullery. We only had cold running water, a gas cooker and wooden table, and back yard. The whole family, nine of us at the time had to wash there, but when it was bath time we only had a metal bath with water poured from the fireplace, and the three younger girls were bathed together in this boat like tub. There was a time when there was a shortage of fuel when I was about eleven and every family was rationed one sack of coal. We had to go and collect the coal from Flower and Dean Street (or Fashion Street) and had to line up.

Now, as my walk confirmed, there is hardly any sign of the Jewish presence in Wentworth Street. Instead this area is home to a new set of immigrants and their British born descendants. The larget and most visible migrant group (akin to the Jewish residents in the 1880s that Booth remarked upon) are the Bangladeshis, most of whom trace their roots to Sylheti in the northeast of the country. They are Muslim and established their first roots in the area as early as 1910 and it took them until the early 1980s to win permission to build a mosque.

If you want to have any sense of the Wentworth Street that Booth described as ‘a foreign market’ in the 1890s then take the underground to Whitechapel and wander along the market stalls that throng beside Whitechapel High Street opposite the London Hospital. Close your eyes, and imagine yourself transported back in time.

Entering the abyss: a walk around late 19th century Whitechapel

Screen Shot 2020-02-08 at 14.22.14

This week I took myself down to East London to stretch my legs walking around the area that has become synonymous with the ‘Jack the Ripper’ murders of 1888. Armed with a camera, a voice recorder, and Charles Booth’s guide to the streets of the 1890s I ventured forth, like a ‘slummer’ might have 130 years previously.

I started at the entrance to Gunthorpe Street, under the archway that serves as a portal into what Jack London dubbed ‘the abyss’ in his ‘1903 account of going ‘undercover’ amongst the London poor.

‘You don’t want live down there!’ his friends told him.

‘Why, it is said there are places where a man’s life isn’t worth tuppence’, they warned him.

In 1889 Charles Booth’s maps had revealed the East End as an area of desperate poverty; much worse even that he had anticipated and the socialist revolutionary Henry Hyndeman had claimed.

As you hopefully see from the insert map above the streets above the Whitechapel High Street were dark – coloured blue and black (for ‘very poor’ to ‘vicious, criminal’) with patches of pink (which simply denoted these houses were less poor by comparison). Where there was red (for middle-class ‘well-to-do’) it was concentrated on the commercial buildings on the High Street.

I visit this area frequently, always seeking new things to share with my students or to inform my research. This week was no different as this is an area in a constant state of change. This time however, I thought I’d record my observations as an experiment in starting to create a semi-regular podcast.

Screen Shot 2020-02-08 at 14.22.41

Walking up from the Whitechapel High Street I took in Gunthorpe Street (once George Street and George Yard – where Martha Tabram was murdered), to Wenthworth Street and the old Flower and Dean Street rookery. In the 1880s several of ‘Jack the Ripper’s victims lived in and around Flower & Dean Street, and Thrawl Street and this was also the centre of Jewish East London in the 1880s.

You can listen to my walk here

its my first attempt, so I apologise in advance for its very unpolished state! I will get better at this.

Drew